Climate silence
The majority of Christian leaders in the U.S. believe humans are responsible for climate change, but most do not share that understanding with their congregants, according to a new report published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
A survey of 1,600 U.S. religious leaders found that nearly 90 percent of Christian leaders believe in anthropogenic climate change to some degree. This includes 60 percent who believe humans play a major role and an additional 30 percent who believe that the human role is a more minor one, according to the report.
Yet roughly half the religious leaders have never discussed it with their congregation, and only a quarter have mentioned it more than once or twice, the survey found.
Gregg Sparkman (Lee Pellegrini)
鈥淏ecause of leadership鈥檚 silence on the matter, rank-and-file Christians think most of their leaders do not believe, and feel hesitant to even discuss climate change with their fellow churchgoers,鈥� said Assistant Professor of Psychology Gregg Sparkman, who completed the study with Stylianos Syropoulos, a postdoctoral researcher at BC and now an assistant professor at Arizona State University.
鈥淏ut, if you inform Christians that there's actually a strong consensus among their religious leaders on the issue, they infer belief in climate change is more common in their church generally, feel taking climate action is consistent with their church's values, and feel voting for a political candidate who fails to take climate action is inconsistent with their church's values,鈥� added Sparkman, who directs the at 黑料官网 College.听
The researchers report than in a second survey of nearly 1,000 American Christians representative of major denominations, respondents estimated that roughly half of their leaders did not believe humans are responsible for climate change, when in fact only about 10 percent of Christian leaders denied humans drive climate change. Conversely, having a religious leader who talks about climate change predicts greater willingness to discuss it with fellow churchgoers and attend climate events, the researchers found.
A third set of survey results came from nearly 1,000 American Christians, including about half the respondents who were informed that 90 percent of Christian leaders believe in man-made climate change. The experiment found awareness of that fact reduced congregants鈥� misperception of religious leaders, increased their perception that other church members believe in and are open to discussing climate change, and led Christians to believe that taking climate action is consistent with their church鈥檚 values while voting for politicians that won鈥檛 take climate action is not.
Christianity is the prevalent religion in the United States, observed by 224 million people, or 67 percent of the population, according to a Gallup survey from 2023 The majority of Christian Americans are Protestant Christians.
Earlier research has examined the effects of informing people that there is consensus among scientists about climate change. But until now, it wasn鈥檛 clear whether there was a strong consensus among religious leaders, even though this group is very influential for many Americans, particularly those who may be skeptical of climate science, said Syropoulos.
“Nine out of ten Christian leaders already believe we can do something about climate change. And if this truth gets out and they break their silence, it will help Christian Americans come to faith on this dire issue. ”
Sparkman said there was an expectation that a large percentage of Christian leaders accepted that climate change exists and is driven by human activity, but learning that nine out of 10 leaders accepted the scientific consensus was surprising.
鈥淲e thought most religious leaders would believe,鈥� said Sparkman. 鈥淏ut we didn't expect just how high it would be. For instance, more than 80 percent of Evangelical or Fundamentalist Christian leaders believe in climate change and that humans contribute to it. We also thought religious leaders may self silence more in cases where their congregations were more conservative than they were, out of a fear of 鈥榬ocking the boat鈥�. But in fact, the self-silencing was pretty common whether or not religious leaders felt they had different political attitudes than their congregation.鈥�
Syropoulos and Sparkman agree that an important next step is to engage in greater research efforts highlighting that concern for climate change is high in religious groups in the U.S., with an emphasis on refining and disseminating such consensus beliefs to churchgoers across the country.
鈥淲e find that informing Christians that the majority of their religious leaders believe in man-made climate change leads them to realize that climate action is in line with their morals, and voting for politicians who deny climate change may be at odds with their faith,鈥� Sparkman said. 鈥淓very year we see more droughts, fires, floods, and famines. Nine out of ten Christian leaders already believe we can do something about climate change. And if this truth gets out and they break their silence, it will help Christian Americans come to faith on this dire issue.鈥�
听